By JIM WALSH
Courier-Post Staff
A former assistant to Rabbi Fred Neulander has written
the first insider account of the scandal that rocked South
Jersey with tales of adultery, betrayal and murder.
But the book by Rabbi Gary Mazo is not a tawdry tell-all
about Neulander, who faces trial on charges that he
arranged the Nov. 1, 1994, slaying of his wife, Carol. It
details the spiritual journey of Mazo and members of
Congregation M'kor Shalom, the Cherry Hill temple founded
by Neulander in 1974.
The book also offers a sometimes unflattering portrait of
Neulander, who was once Mazo's mentor. And it sharply
criticizes law enforcement officials and media members,
saying their actions in the sensational case were often
insensitive to Jews.
Some M'kor Shalom members have criticized the book. But
Mazo says he wrote it to show how the embattled
congregation, bound by ties of faith and community,
overcame adversity.
"My hope is that anyone who has endured any sort of a
crisis or tragedy can find a message here that helps them.
That would be the only important thing for me as a rabbi,"
says Mazo, who left M'kor Shalom in 1999 for his current
post at a Cape Cod, Mass., synagogue.
The slim paperback, which includes several sermons among
its 172 pages, shuns "all the salacious details that would
surely have put the book on the best-seller list," Mazo
notes.
Indeed, other than members of the Mazo and Neulander
families, the book identifies no one by name.
"I think the lesson I was trying to teach could get lost
if people got caught up in the who's who. And I didn't want
to hurt anybody," says Mazo, who notes Jewish law forbids
gossip.
The rabbi says he rejected two lucrative offers from large
publishers seeking explicit accounts. Instead, he took a $1,
100 advance from Rising Star Press, a small California
publisher that agreed with his religious emphasis.
The title - And the Flames Did Not Consume Us, A Rabbi's
Journey through Communal Crisis - refers to the biblical
account of a burning bush, in which God appeared to Moses.
Mazo spent nine years at M'kor Shalom, rising from
associate rabbi to senior rabbi. Neulander resigned in
February 1995, when the public learned he was a murder
suspect and had engaged in extramarital affairs.
Authorities contend Neulander had his wife beaten to death
at their Cherry Hill home so he could continue an affair
with Elaine Soncini, a former Philadelphia radio
personality. Two men, Leonard Jenoff of Collingswood and
Paul Daniels of Pennsauken, last year admitted their role
in the killing.
They are expected to testify against Neulander when his
capital murder trial begins in September. Mazo, 37, also is
expected to testify for the defense and the prosecution.
In his book, Mazo expresses grief for Carol Neulander and
compassion for her three grown children. He recounts saying
a ritual prayer over Carol Neulander's battered body, then
breaking the news of her death to her youngest son a short
time later.
His views seem mixed toward Rabbi Neulander.
Mazo describes the rabbi as a charismatic speaker and
teacher who drew the attention of attractive women. He also
says Neulander, who is short but powerfully built, could be
an angry, intimidating man.
"No one knows for sure what goes on inside another person'
s mind, but here's my best guess," says Mazo, adding
Neulander is innocent unless proved guilty. "The
intimidation he was able to inflict on others through his
intellectual and physical power eventually led to
arrogance, perhaps to narcissism; perhaps to hubris. He
went beyond the rules that applied to lesser people - the
ego trap that has destroyed so many charismatic leaders.
"He acted on the fantasies and betrayed the trust of
thousands."
Mazo also criticizes investigators and reporters, saying
their actions sometimes hurt temple members.
He suggests law enforcement officials repeatedly leaked
news and scheduled events to publicize the Neulander case
around the time of the Jewish High Holy Days.
Mazo points to September 1997, when Camden County
Prosecutor Lee Solomon held a grand jury investigation two
weeks before the Jewish holidays.
"There was no compelling reason to schedule the
proceedings at that time," writes Mazo, who testified
before the grand jurors. He speculates that Solomon, who is
Jewish, was trying to show he was not biased in favor of
the rabbi.
Solomon rejects that view. "I have to do the job that I
took an oath to do, without concern for what Rabbi Mazo or
anyone else may think of me," he says. "I did it for the
right reason."
Mazo himself has faced criticism, including some rebukes
from M'kor Shalom members, says Carl Goldman of Rising Star
Press.
He says an order for 25 books came earlier this year for a
book fair at the Jewish Community Center in Cherry Hill,
then was promptly canceled. Robin Rudofker, a spokeswoman
for the JCC, declined to comment.
Sharla Feldscher, a a a spokeswoman for M'kor Shalom, says
the congregation's 900-plus families "have varied opinions
on different topics. In regard to Rabbi Mazo's book, we are
making it available through our library."